The Welsh political landscape is heating up, and the First Minister's Questions session on November 4th, 2025, is a testament to that. But what's the buzz all about?
The Deputy Steps In:
Deputy First Minister Huw Irranca-Davies takes the spotlight, standing in for Eluned Morgan. A significant moment, as the Deputy's role is often a pivotal one in the political arena.
Welsh Students, Where Art Thou?
Plaid Cymru's Cefin Campbell raises a pressing issue: the exodus of Welsh-speaking students to universities in England. With nearly half of Welsh-medium school graduates opting for England, it's a trend that sparks concern. But why the concern? Well, it's a complex issue, and here's where it gets controversial...
Cefin Campbell argues that Wales needs to retain its young Welsh-speaking talent to sustain bilingual public services. He believes that students who leave often lose touch with their language, which is a loss for the community. But is this a fair assessment? Are students truly turning their backs on their heritage, or is it a natural part of personal growth and exploration?
Huw Irranca-Davies offers a different perspective, emphasizing the importance of enabling Welsh students to study wherever they choose. He highlights the Cadw Cyswllt scheme, a network supporting Welsh-speaking students outside Wales. But is this enough to address the concerns of Welsh-speaking communities?
The Seren Scheme: A Starry-Eyed Reform?
Cefin Campbell calls for a reform of the Seren scheme, originally aimed at boosting Welsh students' entry into top UK universities. He believes it's time to refocus efforts on keeping Welsh-speaking students in Wales. But is this a realistic expectation, or a limitation on students' aspirations?
A Clash of Visions:
The debate intensifies as Conservative Tom Giffard accuses Plaid Cymru of lacking ambition for Welsh youth. He argues that studying in prestigious universities across the UK is a positive step, not a cause for concern. But is this a fair criticism, or a political maneuver?
Tom Giffard adds that Wales should focus on economic growth to attract students back, but is this a comprehensive solution? Shouldn't the focus be on creating opportunities within Wales, rather than relying on external factors?
Labour's Report: A Timely Implementation?
Labour's John Griffiths pushes for the implementation of a report recommending the devolution of youth justice and probation powers to Wales. But is this a step towards greater autonomy, or a political strategy?
Huw Irranca-Davies assures that the Welsh government is actively working on these recommendations, highlighting their commitment to industrial clusters and economic rebalancing. But is this a genuine effort, or a political promise?
By-Election Victory: A Wake-Up Call?
Plaid Cymru's Rhun ap Iorwerth celebrates his party's by-election win, attributing it to their positive vision. He criticizes Labour's misleading campaign tactics, suggesting they opened the door to the populist right. But is this a fair assessment, or a political jab?
Rhun ap Iorwerth demands policy changes, questioning Labour's commitment to listening to the public. But is this a genuine call for action, or a political strategy to capitalize on Labour's recent losses?
The Welsh NHS: Broken or Under Pressure?
Darren Millar, leader of the Welsh Conservatives, accuses the Labour government of breaking its promise to eliminate long NHS waits. He highlights the stark contrast between Wales and England's NHS performance. But is this a fair comparison, or a political tactic?
Huw Irranca-Davies defends the Welsh NHS, acknowledging the pressure it's under but refuting claims of it being 'broken'. He counters by pointing out the opposition's historical stance against the NHS. But is this a valid defense, or a distraction from the issue at hand?
Rural Schools: A Future in Question?
Conservative Janet Finch-Saunders raises concerns about the future of two rural schools, citing potential procedural irregularities. But is this a genuine concern for education, or a political strategy?
Huw Irranca-Davies assures that the Welsh government's school organization code is being followed, with a consultation process underway. But is this a sufficient response, or a bureaucratic delay?
A New Face in the Senedd:
Lindsay Whittle, newly elected MS for Caerphilly, is welcomed to the Senedd. He pays tribute to his predecessor, Hefin David, who passed away suddenly. A solemn reminder of the human side of politics.
First Minister's Questions: A Political Theater:
The session, held in the original debating chamber due to renovations, is a hybrid affair. A fitting setting for a political drama that raises questions about Wales' future. But what's your take on these issues? Do you agree with the concerns raised, or do you see a different perspective? The political landscape is ever-evolving, and your voice matters in shaping it.
